Overview

While prevailing accounts of victim participation often frame victims as holders of primarily private interests, victims in common law jurisdictions have increasingly emerged as active public participants in criminal justice systems. With a comparative focus on England and Wales and the United States, Victims as Agents of State Accountability recharacterizes victims as agents of accountability in state decision-making. Through historical, empirical, and case-based analysis, this book advances a normative framework that positions the victim's role as a civic duty, enhancing transparency, legitimacy, and substantive equality in prosecutorial decisions. Accordingly, mechanisms of state accountability are examined, such as private prosecutions, judicial review, and internal review schemes, illustrating how their potential for accountability differs depending on whether victims are recognised as advancing primarily public or private interests. Case studies demonstrate the limits of conceiving victim interests as private and the possibilities of substantive assessments of prosecutorial decisions when interests are understood as public. Ultimately, the book contributes to debates in criminal law and justice by proposing an accountability role that is reflexive and equality-driven. Its comparative and normative insights provide guidance for common law jurisdictions and beyond, highlighting the importance of recognising victims as legitimate participants in shaping the public interest and holding the state accountable within criminal justice.

Full Product Details

9780198885313

Table of Contents

Reviews

Author Information

Marie Manikis is an Associate Professor and William Dawson Scholar at the Faculty of Law, McGill University and a Research Associate at the Centre for Criminology, University of Oxford and at the International Centre for Comparative Criminology. She has published research in leading peer-reviewed journals, including the Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, the Cambridge Law Journal, and the Modern Law Review. She is the co-editor of Sentencing, Public Opinion, and Criminal Justice (OUP 2025).

Tab Content 6

Countries Available